The Redditors Who Reclaimed r/FatPussy (and Different Vile Subs)
In order for you to see the most effective of Reddit, go to r/WhitePolitics, r/faggots, or r/FatPussy. You’ll not discover sickos and slurs there—not anymore, anyway. As an alternative, these subreddits are obsessive about, respectively: the colour white, bundles of sticks, and slightly massive cats.
Up to now few years, Reddit communities as soon as dedicated to outré topics, every thing from InfoWars’ Alex Jones to objectifying tall girls, have seen themselves hijacked and changed by tame, typically literal-minded send-ups of their unique goal. It’s totally humorous, it’s totally Reddit, and it is all of the doing of a band of counter-trolling moderators who take their duties very severely. Their antics are simple to root for. What’s much less understood is how these people function—and at what value. Trolling the trolls, it seems, takes a toll.
First, contemplate traditional trolling: the icky form. It takes time and group, and people are its practitioners’ greatest weaknesses. If you are going to pop up like a hobgoblin sowing discord in feedback sections throughout the web, you’ll be able to’t spend too many sources in anyone place. Far-right trolls, particularly, are notoriously disorganized and vulnerable to infighting. Which means there are an terrible lot of hateful however poorly moderated subreddits on the market, ripe for the hijacking.
The work of changing these swamps into arable webland is tough—and infrequently deeply private. (Although some mods say it is “only for shits and giggles.”) The primary job is figuring out hateful subreddits, tracked at locations like r/AgainstHateSubs. As soon as you discover one, lurk on the threads for some time, getting a way of who’s there and what they’re saying. However keep quiet: You may share an id with the group the sub is designed to assault, so it is best to not appeal to consideration. Then, you wait. Be certain that the earlier moderators have been asleep on the change for 60 days or extra and submit a request to directors to be made the brand new mod. Voilà. The subreddit is yours.
Drewie, who has been a redditor for greater than seven years and moderates greater than 50 subreddits, has at all times stored a watch on subs that sting her most. She’s trans and is aware of the harms and humiliations the web can convey. She has a string of profitable hijackings to her identify—communities like r/Trannys (now about automotive transmissions) and r/Dykes (you realize, like water-retaining embankments) make up her kingdom. Her most up-to-date conquest was r/AlexJones, however the one she remembers finest is r/faggots. She’d been eyeing the group from a distance for some time, however then there was rumbling amongst Reddit’s moderators: The deposed alt-right troll king Milo Yiannopoulos had simply requested management of the sub.
Controversy ensued, however with no opposition, the directors would possible grant it to him. Drewie would not have it. Yiannopoulos is a Gamergate alum, professional at trolling the individuals she needed to guard; r/faggots, she feared, would turn out to be one other platform to rally his troops. She submitted a counter request, telling the admins she deliberate to make the hate sub into one thing enjoyable and satirical. They gave her the keys as a substitute.
Drewie’s vigilante techniques is perhaps within the service of fine, however they had been pioneered by the very trolls she’s making an attempt to struggle.
Since harassment and bullying are verboten, Drewie promptly scrubbed r/faggots of hateful posts and posters, turning the subreddit into an empty house for her and her allies to fill in. She thinks she gained over the admins—who’re infamous for leaving moderators to scrap out issues on their very own, it doesn’t matter what sort of hate speech redditors are spewing—by making them snort. For Drewie, although, changing homophobia with piles of sticks is about greater than the lulz. “I am Asian, I’ve a middle-class job, I move, however numerous the individuals I do know do not,” she says. “I’ve to make use of that to do one thing. I can not simply sit down and say, ‘Oh, I’ve received it good.’ I’ve no selection.”
Not everybody sees it so unambiguously. Drewie’s vigilante techniques is perhaps within the service of fine, however they had been pioneered by the very trolls she’s making an attempt to struggle. To Whitney Phillips, writer of a number of books on on-line trolling, the anti-hate hijacking of subreddits most carefully resembles the “RIP trolling” circa 2011. “If, for instance, a lady had been murdered by her husband, the troll would make a seemingly legit RIP web page designed to get probably the most responses and followers potential,” Phillips says. Then, as soon as the honeypot had attracted sufficient flies, the troll was free to flip the tone of the web page fully, utilizing it to mock the deceased and threaten those that sympathized with them.
Over time, this tone-flipping tactic grew to become much less randomly malicious and extra focused. Earlier than being banned from Reddit, r/antifa wasn’t a stronghold of the controversial antifascist motion however one among alt-right trolls pretending to be antifa so as to make the motion look unhealthy—and possibly entice some naifs to a faux protest or two. It is also the identical college of trolling that is given us Russian operatives posing as black activists on Fb.
Little about this could recommend that these trolling strategies would ever be used for social justice on Reddit. They rely, of their unique conception, on mockery and exclusion, not acceptance and bonhomie. As Phillips places it: “Why would any progressive aspire to one thing so regressive? It in a short time turns into a dialog about whether or not the grasp’s instruments can ever be used to dismantle the grasp’s home.”
“Why would any progressive aspire to one thing so regressive? It in a short time turns into a dialog about whether or not the grasp’s instruments can ever be used to dismantle the grasp’s home.”
Writer Whitney Phillips
There are two methods to consider that. The primary is, do the instruments work? This grasp’s home is constructed from bricks of bigotry. In line with Casey Fiesler, who research on-line governance on the College of Colorado, ousting homophobes and white supremacists and purveyors of nonconsensual pornography from their strongholds is unlikely to vary their minds—and a few researchers fear that pushing these individuals into ever-more-fringe areas of the web will solely improve their extremism. Lots of the hijacked communities have certainly regrouped elsewhere below a unique spelling or a unique identify. Nonetheless, it’s important to be deep on this planet so as to discover these new locales. Maybe the informal searcher—the 14-year-old child typing slurs into Reddit—will not expend the hassle.
The second a part of the counter-trolling ethical conundrum is extra existential: What do these instruments do to the one that wields them? “It’s exhausting!” Drewie says. “I’d love not to do that. You get no profit, you simply lose time.” On high of a full-time job, she spends no less than 5 hours a day scouring Reddit for hate and monitoring the subreddits she’s hijacked, and that does not even embody peeking between conferences, throughout lunch, or on her commute. She thinks of doxing and dying threats—inevitable on this line of activism—as “the price of doing enterprise.” The choice is worse. “I get by means of the day by telling myself it is simply web trolls. However I’ve misplaced so many pals who cannot take the hate,” she says. “I do not wish to go to a different memorial.”
At occasions, the purpose of those moderators appears unattainable. Hate on the web is a hydra: Lower off one supply and three extra rear up. Nazis nonetheless publish; cyberbullying nonetheless occurs. And since these mods desire to remain nameless, they’re hardly ever acknowledged for his or her work. (Many of the mods I reached out to by no means returned my request for an interview.)
Observers like Fiesler say the distinction they make is subtler, incremental shifts in Reddit’s tone and ethos. “These individuals are signposting what it means to be Reddit,” Fiesler says. “It exhibits individuals the facility you’ll be able to have as a moderator to vary the tradition of a group. Even if you happen to’re not taking up subreddits your self, you is perhaps emboldened to say, ‘Hey, possibly we should always ban hate speech.'” These trolls will not be capable to dismantle the grasp’s home fully, however possibly their efforts can clear house to put new foundations.